First it was probiotics, then collagen, and now creatine is everywhere. It seems like there’s a revolving door of “must-have” supplements, each touted as the answer to more energy, better sleep, glowing skin, or a longer life.

Walk down the supplement aisle of nearly any store and chances are you’ll feel overwhelmed by the endless options and health claims (as many as 100,000 different supplement products are sold in stores and online in the U.S.). Roughly 75 percent of Americans take a dietary supplement, but between influencers pushing their favorites, clever marketing, and all the noise around supplements, separating the products backed by science from those that are simply overhyped isn’t exactly easy.

While any supplement can never replace a nutrient-rich diet, regular movement, restorative sleep, and stress management, a handful are supported by research and can help fill common nutritional gaps or boost overall health. Here are five supplements the experts I spoke with say are actually worth considering for everyday wellness. (As always, talk to your doctor about your specific needs before trying a new supplement). 

Supplements

Credit: Pexels

Read more: The Best Tasting Herbal Teas For Sleep You’ll Actually Want To Drink

Vitamin D3

While sunlight is the best source of vitamin D, many of us don’t make enough of it from sun exposure alone. Modern life means we’re spending more time indoors, and factors like where you live, the season, time of day, skin tone, and whether you’re wearing sunscreen can affect how much vitamin D is produced in the body. 

If Dr. Sara Siavoshi, a triple board-certified physician in neurology and founder and CEO of DrBrainRx, could convince more people to take one supplement, it would be vitamin D. “Unlike many vitamins, it’s difficult for many people to maintain optimal levels [of vitamin D] through diet alone,” Dr. Siavoshi says. “Yes, sunlight helps, but I’m not recommending people chase UV exposure at the expense of increasing skin cancer risk or accelerating skin aging.”

Kristin Kirkpatrick, MS, RDN, a dietitian at the Cleveland Clinic Department of Wellness and Preventive Medicine, adds that because few foods naturally contain significant amounts of vitamin D, deficiency is common. The Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) is 600IU per day for most adults and 800IU per day after age 70, though individual needs may vary. Low vitamin D is most often associated with weakened immunity, poor mood, muscle weakness, and bone health issues. 

Maintaining optimal vitamin D levels, on the other hand, can not only support bone health and immune function, but Dr. Siavoshi says it may also promote healthy brain cells and keep the nervous system working as it should. For menopausal women, Kirkpatrick notes that adequate vitamin D levels may help ease symptoms of anxiety and depression.

A simple blood test can tell you whether your vitamin D levels are low. If you have persistent fatigue that doesn’t improve with sleep, unexplained muscle weakness or bone pain, mood changes or depression (especially in the winter), or multiple risk factors for deficiency, such as limited sun exposure or darker skin, consider asking your doctor whether checking your vitamin D levels or taking a supplement makes sense for you.

Creatine Monohydrate

“Creatine has quietly become one of the most evidence-backed supplements available,” Dr. Siavoshi says. Though nothing new and once thought to be reserved for bodybuilders and athletes, growing evidence shows that creatine helps muscles rapidly regenerate energy, which can improve strength and exercise performance. But creatine’s potential benefits extend beyond your workout routine. “More recently, research has shown promise for supporting brain energy metabolism, healthy aging, and potentially reducing the risk or slowing progression of certain neurodegenerative diseases, although more research is still needed,” she continues. 

What’s more, a 2020 study published in Translational Psychiatry found that daily creatine supplementation may have antidepressant-like effects, namely on women. Another study in Obstetrics & Gynecology showed that the female reproductive cycle is directly linked to the body’s creatine levels, which may explain why creatine can help alleviate PMS, pregnancy, postpartum, and menopausal symptoms. 

About half of your body’s creatine supply (one to two grams per day) comes from foods like meat and seafood (think protein-rich foods), while the other half your body produces on its own. Dr. Siavoshi says adults who strength train, older adults trying to preserve muscle, vegetarians and vegans, people focused on healthy brain aging, and those with a high risk or family history of dementia could benefit most from taking the supplement. While there are a few different types of creatine, including monohydrate, hydrochloride (HCl), and ethyl ester, creatine monohydrate is the most studied form, and research most commonly supports a daily dose of three to five grams of it. 

Protein Supplements

We’re living in the golden age of protein, where “high-protein” everything—from bars and cereals to popcorn and ice cream—has taken over grocery shelves. But Dr. Siavoshi says protein powder isn’t just a fitness supplement; it’s often a practical nutrition tool.

“Many adults simply don’t consume enough protein, especially older adults, busy professionals, vegetarians, and patients taking GLP-1 medications who often lose their appetite and unintentionally under-eat protein,” she notes. “A shake isn’t replacing healthy food—it’s helping people consistently meet protein goals they otherwise wouldn’t reach.”

Kirkpatrick agrees, adding that sufficient protein becomes even more essential for protecting muscle mass, particularly for those taking GLP-1 medications. Though whole-food protein sources like beans, lentils, eggs, and fermented dairy should come first, a protein supplement can make it easier for people on GLP-1 medications, athletes, vegetarians, vegans, or anyone who struggles to consistently get enough protein.

When it comes to choosing a protein supplement, whey protein is Kirkpatrick’s first choice, unless someone is vegan and prefers supplementing with a plant-based protein. “Research shows that whey protein is one of the highest-quality protein sources for supporting growth, muscle development, and general nutrition,” she says. “It also appears to have benefits beyond protein alone, including supporting a robust gut microbiome, which plays an important role in overall health.” You can find whey protein in the form of powders and drinks and protein-infused snacks, such as popcorn or almond crackers. “The most important aspect is quality and finding protein supplementation that does not contain a lot of additives like sugar or artificial sweeteners,” she adds. 

So, how much protein should you eat each day? There isn’t a single magic number that applies to everyone—your protein needs can vary depending on your age, sex, body composition, activity level, and life stage—but as a general guideline, the RDA recommends 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram per day (for a 150-pound adult, that comes out to 80 to 110 grams a day). That’s where a practical visual cue can come in handy: aim to include a palm-sized serving of protein at each meal.

Taking supplements

Credit: Pexels

Read more: A Gentler Response to Constant Optimization: Inside Slowmaxxing

Fiber Supplements

Fiber may not be the most glamorous nutrient, but it’s one that brings a lot to the table—and one that many of us aren’t getting enough of. In fact, about 95 percent of Americans fall short of the recommended daily amount. Women should aim for about 25 grams of fiber per day and men about 38 grams, yet the average intake hovers around just 15 grams daily (or less), thanks in part to diets that favor processed foods over fiber-rich choices like fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and beans.

According to Dr. Siavoshi, reaching your daily fiber needs has wide-ranging health perks: boosting digestive health, helping prevent constipation, improving cholesterol levels, supporting cardiovascular health, feeding the beneficial bacteria in the gut microbiome which can help fight inflammation, and regulating blood sugar. “While I’d always encourage people to eat more fruits, vegetables, legumes, and whole grains, a fiber supplement can be an easy way to close the gap when diet falls short,” she says. 

If your diet regularly misses the mark on fiber, a supplement like psyllium may be worth adding to your wellness regimen, especially if you experience constipation, have elevated cholesterol, or have blood sugar concerns, Dr. Siavoshi shares. That said, because every body is unique, and every type of fiber supplement—whether it’s a pill or a powder, soluble or insoluble—offers its own particular advantages, discuss any symptoms you have with your healthcare provider first. And when increasing your fiber intake, start slowly and drink plenty of water to minimize digestive discomfort.

Omega-3 Fatty Acids (EPA/DHA)

While the latest “it” supplement comes and goes, omega-3 fatty acids have stood the test of time. “Omega-3s containing EPA and DHA remain one of the most-studied supplements in medicine,” Dr. Siavoshi says. “They play an important role in lo heart health, triglyceride reduction, and normal brain function.” EPA and DHA are the main forms of omega-3s found in fatty fish and are most closely linked to heart and brain health. 

Omega-3s are essential fats that your body can’t make itself, so we have to depend on food or supplements to get them. The American Heart Association (AHA) recommends eating two servings of fatty fish per week (about 500 milligrams of EPA and DHA per day) to support overall heart health. But unless you’re eating salmon, sardines, mackerel, or herring multiple times per week (many of us don’t), Dr. Siavoshi says an omega-3 supplement is a reasonable option to help increase your intake. 

Some studies also suggest that supplementing with EPA and DHA may be effective in reducing symptoms of depression, and more research is exploring how it may help lower the risk of dementia, Kirkpatrick points out.

To get the most from your omega-3 supplement, take it alongside a meal containing healthy fats (think avocado, nuts, chia or flaxseeds, or Greek yogurt), which makes it easier for the body to absorb.

The Bottom Line

You can’t supplement your way to good health. “Lifestyle always comes first,” Dr. Siavoshi emphasizes. “Supplements work best when they’re used to fill a real gap—not as a shortcut around healthy habits.”

However, some nutrients can be difficult for many people to consistently meet their needs for, even with a well-balanced diet. For example, Dr. Siavoshi says you can have an excellent diet and still have low vitamin D levels because of where you live, your skin tone, sunscreen use, or limited sun exposure. Likewise, you can eat well and still struggle to get enough protein, especially if you’re over 50 or taking a GLP-1 medication. 

Kirkpatrick agrees that while some supplements—such as vitamin D and creatine—fall into a “worth considering” category for many people, most supplementation should be guided by data, like blood work, your diet, and health history. “Supplement choice and dosing should be directly tied to deficiencies and individual needs, not guesswork,” she says. 

So when choosing a supplement, what should you look for? Dr. Siavoshi recommends focusing on quality over marketing promises. Look for products that:

  • Have been independently third-party tested by organizations such as USP, NSF Certified for Sport, or ConsumerLab
  • Are transparent about their ingredients and manufacturing practices
  • Clearly disclose ingredient amounts (steer clear of proprietary blends that don’t)
  • Avoid dramatic claims like “boosts immunity overnight” or “reverses aging”

“Ultimately, I’d rather someone take a few evidence-based supplements consistently than spend hundreds of dollars each month on a cabinet full of trendy products with little scientific support,” Dr. Siavoshi says. 

Taking supplements

Credit: Pexels

Read more: The Science-Backed Habits That Can Help You Become a Morning Person

Have feedback on our story? Email [email protected] to let us know what you think! 

Shop Pillows

The Essential Organic Pillow Collection

Gentle, breathable, non-toxic support.

Buy Now